Performance and Application Analysis of Various Crucible Materials

There are various types of crucibles available, each designed to meet specific application needs. These include alumina, magnesia, zirconia, boron nitride, silicon carbide, graphite, and quartz crucibles. Each material offers unique thermal resistance and chemical stability, making them suitable for different high-temperature experiments and industrial processes.
Performance Advantages of Crucible Materials

Alumina Crucible

• Advantages: Alumina crucibles are highly resistant to temperatures ranging from 1500°C to 1650°C. They also exhibit excellent corrosion resistance, particularly against most acids (except hydrofluoric acid), and boast strong chemical stability.
  
  
• Applications: Alumina crucibles are widely used in laboratories, alloy smelting, and as heating containers in medium to high-frequency induction furnaces, electric furnaces, and vacuum furnaces. They are particularly valuable in material deposition and evaporation processes. In practical applications, the crucible material may react with molten metals, necessitating the use of protective linings (such as nickel or molybdenum) to shield the crucible from corrosion and damage, as well as to prevent contamination of deposited materials by crucible substances like aluminum. However, in certain cases, refractory linings may not be compatible with the metals being processed, so their use should be carefully considered based on specific operating conditions.
  
  
• Disadvantages: Alumina crucibles have relatively low thermal shock resistance, especially during rapid cooling. To enhance thermal shock resistance, it is crucial to control the rate of temperature increase and decrease, avoiding sudden extreme temperature changes. Additionally, during the smelting of certain high-reactivity alloys, crucible materials may react with molten metals, making it essential to strictly control smelting conditions.
  
  
  

  
  Zirconia Crucible

  • Advantages: Zirconia crucibles exhibit extremely high-temperature resistance, with some composite zirconia materials capable of withstanding up to 2400°C. They also offer excellent chemical resistance, low thermal conductivity, and high thermal shock resistance, making them reusable and ideal for repeated use. Partially stabilized zirconia crucibles overcome many drawbacks of other oxide materials, combining strength, refractoriness, thermal shock stability, and chemical inertness. The crucible shown in the image can endure instant heating up to 1500°C, is reusable, and performs reliably at a sustained temperature of 2200°C.
    
    
  • Applications: Zirconia crucibles are suitable for ultra-high-temperature metals and alloys. In vacuum precision investment casting, partially stabilized zirconia ceramics have become the ideal crucible material, particularly successful in casting platinum, nickel-based superalloys, and cobalt-based alloys.
    
    
  • Disadvantages: Compared to alumina and graphite crucibles, zirconia crucibles are more expensive to manufacture.
  
  

  
  
  Magnesia Crucible
  

  • Advantages: Magnesia crucibles have exceptional resistance to alkaline metal slags and are highly effective in vacuum melting processes, especially when used with high-temperature refining treatments. When combined with deoxidizers like carbon (C) and aluminum (Al), these crucibles facilitate the production of CO gas and Al₂O₃ inclusions, efficiently removing free oxygen from molten steel without generating floating slag during the smelting process. However, because magnesia tends to volatilize at temperatures above 2300°C, magnesia ceramic products should be used at temperatures below 2200°C.

  • Disadvantages: The primary drawback of magnesia crucibles is their tendency to decompose, releasing free oxygen and magnesium as the vacuum level and refining temperature increase. When the actual oxygen content in the molten pool falls below the saturation level of dissolved oxygen from the refractory lining, the lining begins to supply oxygen to the molten steel. Therefore, when melting high-temperature alloy grades using magnesia crucibles, it is crucial to carefully control refining temperature and time to prevent the decomposition of the crucible and the unwanted oxygen supply to the molten steel.

  
  
  
  Graphite Crucible
  

  • Advantages: Graphite crucibles are highly resistant to high temperatures and possess excellent thermal conductivity. They also exhibit strong resistance to corrosion by acidic and alkaline solutions, making them a cost-effective option. Graphite crucibles are widely used for melting various non-ferrous metals such as gold, silver, copper, aluminum, lead, and zinc, as well as for medium-carbon steel and rare metals. They are compatible with different types of furnaces, including coke furnaces, oil furnaces, gas furnaces, electric furnaces, and medium to high-frequency induction furnaces.

  • Applications: Graphite crucibles are widely used for melting various non-ferrous metals such as gold, silver, copper, aluminum, lead, and zinc, as well as for medium-carbon steel and rare metals. They are compatible with different types of furnaces, including coke furnaces, oil furnaces, gas furnaces, electric furnaces, and medium to high-frequency induction furnaces.

  • Disadvantages: The primary limitation of graphite crucibles is their poor thermal shock resistance. After heating, they must not be subjected to sudden cooling, as this can cause damage to the crucible.

  
  
  
  Quartz Crucible
  

  • Advantages: Quartz crucibles boast high transparency, excellent heat resistance, and a low coefficient of thermal expansion. Made from high-purity quartz sand, these crucibles are renowned for their high purity, durability, and ability to withstand extreme temperatures.

  • Applications:  They are extensively used in the semiconductor and photovoltaic industries, particularly in the production processes of monocrystalline silicon rods. Quartz crucibles play a critical role in the melting of silicon material and the growth of crystals, making them indispensable consumables in the manufacturing of semiconductor wafers and photovoltaic silicon wafers. In crystal growth furnaces, quartz crucibles serve as heating containers, directly holding polycrystalline silicon material, which is melted and then processed into silicon rods/wafers for further use in downstream semiconductor chips, photovoltaic cells, and other products.

  • Disadvantages: The main limitation of quartz crucibles is their restricted lifespan, typically ranging from 360 to 500 hours of use. Absorbs water easily and is prone to moisture; preheating and baking are required before use.
    
    
    
    
    Silicon Carbide SiC Crucible

  • Advantages: Silicon carbide crucibles are designed to withstand extreme heat, operating effectively at temperatures up to 2000°C in vacuum or inert gas environments and up to 1650°C in air. They excel in oxidation resistance, offering a longer service life—up to one year in aluminum alloy die-casting and 4 to 6 months for melting scrap aluminum. These crucibles are highly resistant to thermal shock and chemical corrosion, with minimal slag adhesion on the inner walls, which reduces heat loss and the potential for cracking. They are ideal for maintaining material purity, ensuring a clean and efficient melting process.
    
    
  • Applications: Perfect for use in hearth, electric, and induction furnaces, silicon carbide
    crucibles are essential for smelting and casting a wide range of non-ferrous metals, including gold, silver, copper, aluminum, lead, and zinc. Additionally, their excellent chemical corrosion resistance and high-temperature stability make them widely used in battery fuel production, as they do not contaminate the anode material.

  • Disadvantages: Despite their many advantages, silicon carbide crucibles have limitations. They exhibit reduced resistance to alkali metal oxides and are susceptible to moisture absorption. Rapid cooling or heating should be avoided, as it can lead to cracking. Additionally, the use of fluxes can shorten the crucible's lifespan.

    
    
    thermal analysis crucibles
    
    We provide a wide range of high-quality thermal analysis crucibles that are fully compatible with popular analytical instruments, including SAT (Simultaneous Thermal Analysis) and TGA (Thermogravimetric Analysis), ensuring reliable and accurate results for your thermal analysis needs.
    
    
    

    Ceramic Crucibles: A Core Product of WEIERT

    Looking for custom ceramic crucible supplier? WEIERT specializes in providing high-quality ceramic crucibles tailored to your needs. Simply provide your required dimensions and material specifications. Unsure of the best material? Share your application requirements, and our experts will recommend the ideal solution. No minimum order quantity required.